Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Ingin merubah A/V sistem, elekrik dan lampu di kendaraan anda? Tanyakan disini..

Moderators: akbarfit, Ryan Steele, sh00t, r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze

kendibocor
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3387
Joined: 10 Aug 2015, 20:13
Location: Jakarta

Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by kendibocor »

Sesuai judul, selama ini pake HID aftermarket lumayan awet jg uda masuk tahun keempat, harga murmer cuma 1 jutaan, sinar terang.

Rencana mo ganti antara lampu HID sama LED aftermarket trus yg skrng dipake di lampu utama mo diturunin jd foglamp. Kira2 masih unggulan HID atau LED ya terutama dari terangnya, dgn catatan harga harus mirip2 jgn bandingin harga 3 jt sama 1 juta :upss:
2022 KS Smartstream 1.5G MPi
2022 DM Skyactiv-G PE-VPS
2019 DJ Skyactiv-G P5 VPS
2016 F30 B48B20
glendotan
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 504
Joined: 21 Jul 2011, 12:44

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by glendotan »

Selama masih pake reflektor sebenernya krg efektif pake 2jenis lampu ini.
Tp kalo dr terangnya ane masih lbh yakin HID lebih terang krn intensitas HID lbh kuat drpd LED.
LED menang watt lbh kecil dan startup cepat.
Ane rasa harga LED ga semahal HID.
kendibocor
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3387
Joined: 10 Aug 2015, 20:13
Location: Jakarta

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by kendibocor »

Kebetulan uda projektor om lampu ane. Tetap lebih terang hid jd ya om. Untuk jangka panjang kira2 lebih awet led atau hid ya. Ini yg skrng saya pake HID 1,2an bs nyala ampe 4 thn oke jg sih melebihi ekspektasi saya
2022 KS Smartstream 1.5G MPi
2022 DM Skyactiv-G PE-VPS
2019 DJ Skyactiv-G P5 VPS
2016 F30 B48B20
tesna
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 697
Joined: 17 Mar 2005, 16:01
Location: Jakarta

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by tesna »

walau hid nyala bertahun-tahun, tapi intensitasnya pasti berkurang. umur hid itu idealnya 400-500 jam nyala harus diganti...(bohlam nya) itu oem lho.. kalau sehari dipake 1 jam.. dalam 1-2 tahun ya idealnya diganti...

nih ada yang udah pernah bandingin:
http://www.jvxdriver.com/Old%20Bulb%20v ... arison.htm

btw.. kalau projectornya di desain untuk HID, ya jangan dikasih LED.. pasti ga optimal sinarnya.. kalau mau ganti LED ya ganti oem projector led juga...
W212 E300 '10
Kijang 2GD '18
octafiantos
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1451
Joined: 11 Nov 2005, 11:10
Location: Hanoi
Daily Vehicle: xebushanoi-18

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by octafiantos »

Saya iseng jualan lampu LED H1, iseng impor berapa pair doang.
Led banyak jenisnya, kalo yang banyak beredar itu jenis lampunya COB. Kira kira kalo 7-5.8watt itu setara halogen 80w. Kalo yang sangat bagus seperti HID itu pake jenis CREE, itu pun juga tipenya masih macem macem dan harganya sangat mahal. Led biasa (kita omong yang biasa yang murmer) yang dipasarin 100an sebiji itu kalo kejar terang HID kalah. Dia kejar lifetime kalo dibanding regular bulb. Dengan asumsi batok udah projektor dan mau kejar sinar terang dengan harga ekonomis, HID lebih tepat. Selain itu pilihan Kelvin temperatur HID lebih luas. Dari kuning (2K-an) sampe biru +7K-an) ada.
Kavling kosong, bisa dikridit.
User avatar
v4ldi5
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 242
Joined: 24 Apr 2007, 19:26

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by v4ldi5 »

Wah ternyata ada yg galau juga mau pake hid atau led. Ane juga kepincut pake led tapi masih mikir2 juga soalnya masih pakai reflektor. Bisa bagi2 info projector led itu merk apa tipe brp? Pengetahuan ane tentang projector masih cupu.
User avatar
sintoni
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 5684
Joined: 05 Jun 2014, 20:03
Daily Vehicle: [cencored]

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by sintoni »

kendibocor wrote:Sesuai judul, selama ini pake HID aftermarket lumayan awet jg uda masuk tahun keempat, harga murmer cuma 1 jutaan, sinar terang.

Rencana mo ganti antara lampu HID sama LED aftermarket trus yg skrng dipake di lampu utama mo diturunin jd foglamp. Kira2 masih unggulan HID atau LED ya terutama dari terangnya, dgn catatan harga harus mirip2 jgn bandingin harga 3 jt sama 1 juta :upss:
Wih, mayan juga om.

Kalo boleh tau HID nya merk apa?
User avatar
bain279
New Member of Senior Mechanic
New Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 146
Joined: 01 May 2008, 23:36
Location: KL-Jakarta

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by bain279 »

octafiantos wrote:Saya iseng jualan lampu LED H1, iseng impor berapa pair doang.
Led banyak jenisnya, kalo yang banyak beredar itu jenis lampunya COB. Kira kira kalo 7-5.8watt itu setara halogen 80w. Kalo yang sangat bagus seperti HID itu pake jenis CREE, itu pun juga tipenya masih macem macem dan harganya sangat mahal. Led biasa (kita omong yang biasa yang murmer) yang dipasarin 100an sebiji itu kalo kejar terang HID kalah. Dia kejar lifetime kalo dibanding regular bulb. Dengan asumsi batok udah projektor dan mau kejar sinar terang dengan harga ekonomis, HID lebih tepat. Selain itu pilihan Kelvin temperatur HID lebih luas. Dari kuning (2K-an) sampe biru +7K-an) ada.
om berarti klo LED bulb pake CREE apakah ngejar terang nya dengan HID? atau tetap lebih terang HID.
KodokPushUp
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 623
Joined: 29 Sep 2014, 02:04
Location: Surabaya

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by KodokPushUp »

Kebetulan gerobak newbie, 1 hid, 1 lg led
Perasaan newbie malah lebih terang led
Entah bener, cuma perasaan, atau gara2 umur hid nya ketuaan. (Umur led sekitar 8 bulan, umur hid 3 tahun, keduanya oem)

Tapi sama2 gelap kalo ujan. Di mata newbie malah enakan pake halogen 100+ watt yg kekuningan
Ikutan trend penghuni garasi:

-antek medket liar entah milik siapa
-ayam milik tetangga depan rumah yg kadang nyasar
-tikus yg siap diracun :evil:
kendibocor
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3387
Joined: 10 Aug 2015, 20:13
Location: Jakarta

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by kendibocor »

sintoni wrote:
kendibocor wrote:Sesuai judul, selama ini pake HID aftermarket lumayan awet jg uda masuk tahun keempat, harga murmer cuma 1 jutaan, sinar terang.

Rencana mo ganti antara lampu HID sama LED aftermarket trus yg skrng dipake di lampu utama mo diturunin jd foglamp. Kira2 masih unggulan HID atau LED ya terutama dari terangnya, dgn catatan harga harus mirip2 jgn bandingin harga 3 jt sama 1 juta :upss:
Wih, mayan juga om.

Kalo boleh tau HID nya merk apa?
Ane pm ya om, biar ga disangka sales HID :upss:
2022 KS Smartstream 1.5G MPi
2022 DM Skyactiv-G PE-VPS
2019 DJ Skyactiv-G P5 VPS
2016 F30 B48B20
ht1188
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 12
Joined: 16 Aug 2016, 14:29

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by ht1188 »

Nanya nih om, batok head lamp aku belum ada proyektor, pingin masang HID (copotan mobil lama, kebetulan ada proyektornya dulu). Nah andaikata aku memakai hid untuk batok ini, reflektor nya gosong ato menguning ga ya? mengingagat panas dari HID. soalnya kata orang HID yg bagus ga panas, padahal semua HID yg nyala panas kok batoknya, kecuali yg ada proyektor ya
User avatar
b8099ok
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 2794
Joined: 18 Nov 2009, 11:14
Location: Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: 2020 All New Xpander Pickup
Contact:

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by b8099ok »

Perubahan energi listrik ke sinar ya pasti panas. Mau hid kek, led kek, obor kek, api unggun buat panggang FRD, tetep aja panas. Cm msh dlm batas wajar gak.
FWD + RWD + 4WD = :big_cat:
martinnn
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2898
Joined: 17 Aug 2015, 13:32
Location: Jabodetabek
Daily Vehicle: Innova gen 1 vvti + Supra X 125 with Givi Top box

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by martinnn »

motor ogut masih reflektor, coba ganti led tancep....

sinarnya sama sekali gk keliatan di jalanan, gak tau kemana nyorotnya
Morv.co.id ( Audio Visual Production )
Astha Jaya Indo ( Distributor LED Lamp and PJU Solar panel , interior and Lighting Designer )

https://api.whatsapp.com/send?phone=6281288415145
User avatar
k0b0chan
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 433
Joined: 15 Feb 2016, 23:19
Location: Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: Anki

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by k0b0chan »

b8099ok wrote:Perubahan energi listrik ke sinar ya pasti panas. Mau hid kek, led kek, obor kek, api unggun buat panggang FRD, tetep aja panas. Cm msh dlm batas wajar gak.
Kalo panasnya itu, menurut watt atau apa ya om? Kadang penasaran, 55watt HID vs 55watt halogen panasan mana. Abis penjual selalu bilang klo pake 55watt hid batok gmpng gosong. Tp kalo 55watt halogen gpp. :ungg:
quyquy
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 656
Joined: 08 Dec 2015, 23:08

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by quyquy »

Bohlamp LED utk headlamp mereknya apa aja ya Om?

Pake heatsink ya? Lgs plug n play?

Pengen gnt dari halogen ke LED. Headlampnya uda pake projector.
arfs
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1344
Joined: 25 Jan 2016, 18:40
Location: Jakarta

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by arfs »

Bicara soal HID, tahun lalu (setelah mobil dipakai 3.5 tahun) bohlam HID OEM sx4 saya mati-nyala satu yg sebelah kanan (merk Koito).
Di ganti dgn merk cungkwo "super vision" 6000K D2S (kiri kanan) hasil nya gk seterang bohlam HID OEM nya. :big_dunno:
“I don’t want to be preached to about cars by someone who doesn’t even know how to drive.” - Hiromu Naruse (TMC Master Test Driver) to Akio Toyoda, 2000.
piggypig77
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 634
Joined: 11 Feb 2014, 20:33
Location: Jakarta

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by piggypig77 »

Saran ane hid aj,karna biarpun masi kalah sama fokus bohlam bawaan pabrik tapi hid punya fokus yg lebih baik dan lbh terang dibanding led aftermarket
cicidanqimy
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 41
Joined: 31 May 2016, 08:35

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by cicidanqimy »

Nanya nih om :
-kl msh reflektor dan lampu std-nya bohlam biasa mau langsung diganti LED bisa ya om ?
-kl bs, apa hasilnya lebih terang om ? LED warna kuning ada kan om ? biar hujan tetep keliatan jalanan
-kl mau ganti lampunya aja pakai LED apa bole watt-nya lebih kecil dari oem yg bohlam om ? biar irit aki :)
-lalu hal ini bisa diterapkan di foglamp juga gak om?

maap ya om banyak nanya, msh nubie bgt ttg lampu2an :0
ths om
kenop
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1083
Joined: 24 Aug 2015, 12:06

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by kenop »

k0b0chan wrote:
b8099ok wrote:Perubahan energi listrik ke sinar ya pasti panas. Mau hid kek, led kek, obor kek, api unggun buat panggang FRD, tetep aja panas. Cm msh dlm batas wajar gak.
Kalo panasnya itu, menurut watt atau apa ya om? Kadang penasaran, 55watt HID vs 55watt halogen panasan mana. Abis penjual selalu bilang klo pake 55watt hid batok gmpng gosong. Tp kalo 55watt halogen gpp. :ungg:
panas nya sih ngga tau jg *blm pernah ukur* tapi klo baca2 sih yg bikin gosong / butek dari HID itu sinar UV nya
klo HID merk abal2 kaca bulb nya kurang oke UV coating nya.. katanya sih begitu :mky_01:
ht1188
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 12
Joined: 16 Aug 2016, 14:29

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by ht1188 »

b8099ok wrote:Perubahan energi listrik ke sinar ya pasti panas. Mau hid kek, led kek, obor kek, api unggun buat panggang FRD, tetep aja panas. Cm msh dlm batas wajar gak.
Bener om.. Kadang penasaran aja andaikata dipasang balik HID (mumpung punya), cuman ya takut dengan efek yg bakal muncul mengingat ga punya proyektor :big_bored:
idlamahilang
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 339
Joined: 01 Jul 2016, 17:16

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by idlamahilang »

martinnn wrote:motor ogut masih reflektor, coba ganti led tancep....

sinarnya sama sekali gk keliatan di jalanan, gak tau kemana nyorotnya
Kalo coba disorot ditembok sinarnya gimana? Ini motor ya bukan mobil?
MasRB
New Member of Junior Mechanic
New Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 15
Joined: 29 Aug 2016, 08:28

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by MasRB »

klo HID enaknya sinarnya padet,klo LED ga perlu warming up saat dinyalakan,HID cocok utk driving,LED cocok buat high beam atau buat yang seneng ngedim2,tp utk HID saran saya cari yang bisa di stel fokusnya biar ga terlalu bocor,hehe
User avatar
Herman7103
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1547
Joined: 03 Oct 2016, 06:17
Location: SOUTH SUMATRA
Daily Vehicle: All New Grand Livina CVT

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by Herman7103 »

Saya ganti HID aftermarket yg 6000K seharga 1 jt untuk lampu head lamp mobil all new grand livina sejak juni 2014 yang sampe sekarang masih terang dan tidak bikin headlamp jadi buram.
User avatar
Duvebriliant0
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 788
Joined: 07 Feb 2016, 16:03
Daily Vehicle: 4 Banger

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by Duvebriliant0 »

Sore om mohon maaf ni bangkitin thread lama. Sy punya altis V 2012 baru ganti bohlam HID 2 biji tapi ternyata lebih redup sebelah (kemungkinan ballast), nah pertanyaan saya apakah ballast yg udh lemah itu bisa buat bohlamnya rusak atau engga? Soalnya harga bohlam dan ballastnya lumayan juga...
It's better to drive a slow car fast than a fast car slow

NCP91R
TGN140R
arnold911
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 12
Joined: 08 Oct 2019, 13:07
Daily Vehicle: Toyota Fortuner VNT 2013

Re: Lampu HID VS LED aftermarket

Post by arnold911 »

kendibocor wrote: 29 Mar 2016, 17:46
sintoni wrote:
kendibocor wrote:Sesuai judul, selama ini pake HID aftermarket lumayan awet jg uda masuk tahun keempat, harga murmer cuma 1 jutaan, sinar terang.

Rencana mo ganti antara lampu HID sama LED aftermarket trus yg skrng dipake di lampu utama mo diturunin jd foglamp. Kira2 masih unggulan HID atau LED ya terutama dari terangnya, dgn catatan harga harus mirip2 jgn bandingin harga 3 jt sama 1 juta :upss:
Wih, mayan juga om.

Kalo boleh tau HID nya merk apa?
Ane pm ya om, biar ga disangka sales HID :upss:
Boleh juga om PM in pake merek apa HID nya
ada rencana maw pasang HID juga hehe
Post Reply
  • Similar Topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post