Compact / city car nyaman

Butuh saran untuk membeli kendaraan untuk pribadi, keluarga ataupun kerja? Silakan dibahas disini...

Moderators: akbarfit, Ryan Steele, sh00t, r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze

supersae
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 92
Joined: Sun Oct 16, 2016 12:53

Compact / city car nyaman

Post by supersae »

compact car(garasi mepet 3x4) Matic suspensi paling nyaman apa ? dana 150 , yg saya tahu:
Ayla
New picanto 2012 up
Karimum wagon
Splash
Mirage
lainya... ?
User avatar
technoholic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 45
Joined: Wed Jun 11, 2014 12:15

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by technoholic »

Yaris bakpao, empukk
2E - 7K - 1NZ - 1TR - 2KD - 2GD
adityawei
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 714
Joined: Mon Nov 30, 2015 1:44
Location: Surakarta
Daily Vehicle: Toyota Kijang Innova V D4D 2013

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by adityawei »

technoholic wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 2:23 Yaris bakpao, empukk
Setujuuu

Option lain jazz GE8, tp ya agak keras
2013 Toyota Grand New Kijang Innova V 2.5 (retired)
2020 CRV RW1 1.5TC
timbermaniac123
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 577
Joined: Wed Sep 18, 2019 16:52
Location: Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: Voxy

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by timbermaniac123 »

katanya si.... spresso empuk... :ngacir:
supersae
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 92
Joined: Sun Oct 16, 2016 12:53

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by supersae »

supersae wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 1:52 compact car(garasi mepet 3x4) Matic suspensi paling nyaman apa ? dana 150 , yg saya tahu:
Ayla
New picanto 2012 up
Karimum wagon
Splash
Mirage
lainya... ?
lupa.... irit buat dlm kota :big_childish:
ariswp
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 521
Joined: Mon Dec 19, 2016 8:39

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by ariswp »

Suspensi nyaman? Jangan honda (saya pelihara 3 ekor honda)

Dana segitu cari bakpao yang taun2 terakhir aja masih dapet kembalian lumayan, bisa buat beres2/peremajaan part2 yg udah minta ganti karena usia

kalo kandidat2 yg ts sebutkan saya no komen,
Present
R20A 5AT 08 / Shell Helix City SP 0w20 / Aisin AFW VI
R18Z CVT 17 / Mobil Super SP 0w20 / HCF2
L12B CVT 17 / Pertamina Fastron Eco SN 0w20 / HCF2

Past
G15B 5MT 00
K20A 5MT 03
J20A 5MT 08
quyquy
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 656
Joined: Tue Dec 08, 2015 16:08

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by quyquy »

Yaris bakpo =》 mobil dng panjang masih dibawah 4 meter, pakai mesin legendaris vios, empuk...

Kalo bisa, cari yang trim S matic

Kenapa?

krn pake keyless,
jok penumpang bisa di geser maju mundur untuk memperluas bagasi tnp melipat jok.
jika butuh lipat rata pun bisa, karena ketika dilipat, jok bagian bawah maju kedpan lalu sandaran joknya terlipat rata lantai. ..

Pelipatan+maju mundur jok penumpang serta keyless ini yg gak ada di trim selain trim S Matic.
User avatar
y_anjasrana
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8855
Joined: Fri Feb 14, 2003 9:05
Location: Jakarta - Tangerang

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by y_anjasrana »

supersae wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 1:52 compact car(garasi mepet 3x4) Matic suspensi paling nyaman apa ? dana 150 , yg saya tahu:
Ayla
New picanto 2012 up
Karimum wagon
Splash
Mirage
lainya... ?
Nissan March
Daihatsu Sirion
Suzuki Spresso
Toyota Etios

umm... apalagi ya.... :big_think:

yang paling nyaman dlm hal apa nih? mending cobain 1-1 aja. feeling di dalam mobil kyk gimana pasti beda2.
kalau ane :
ayla/agya : suspensi ga enak. pernah numpang di taxol.
picanto : nyetirnya enak. yang ga enak terasa sempit banget.
wagon r : kyk naik carry. tapi dalem lumayan lega. cuma tampilan ga semua orang suka.
splash : biasa aja.
mirage : enak nih. tapi lmyn limbung. kalau jalan kenceng berasa naik roller coaster.
sirion : lega. tapi ntah kenapa ga begitu laku.
spresso : belum pernah nyoba.
etios : belum pernah nyoba.
Accurate V5 Accounting System Consultant
supersae
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 92
Joined: Sun Oct 16, 2016 12:53

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by supersae »

ariswp wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 6:22 Suspensi nyaman? Jangan honda (saya pelihara 3 ekor honda)

Dana segitu cari bakpao yang taun2 terakhir aja masih dapet kembalian lumayan, bisa buat beres2/peremajaan part2 yg udah minta ganti karena usia

kalo kandidat2 yg ts sebutkan saya no komen,
termasuk brio om ?
y_anjasrana wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 7:32
supersae wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 1:52 compact car(garasi mepet 3x4) Matic suspensi paling nyaman apa ? dana 150 , yg saya tahu:
Ayla
New picanto 2012 up
Karimum wagon
Splash
Mirage
lainya... ?
Nissan March
Daihatsu Sirion
Suzuki Spresso
Toyota Etios

umm... apalagi ya.... :big_think:

yang paling nyaman dlm hal apa nih? mending cobain 1-1 aja. feeling di dalam mobil kyk gimana pasti beda2.
kalau ane :
ayla/agya : suspensi ga enak. pernah numpang di taxol.
picanto : nyetirnya enak. yang ga enak terasa sempit banget.
wagon r : kyk naik carry. tapi dalem lumayan lega. cuma tampilan ga semua orang suka.
splash : biasa aja.
mirage : enak nih. tapi lmyn limbung. kalau jalan kenceng berasa naik roller coaster.
sirion : lega. tapi ntah kenapa ga begitu laku.
spresso : belum pernah nyoba.
etios : belum pernah nyoba.
yg paling baik nyaman redaman suspensi di jalan keriting , lewat polisitidur semacamnya laah...maklum sering melewati medan seperti itu
supersae
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 92
Joined: Sun Oct 16, 2016 12:53

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by supersae »

quyquy wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 7:29 Yaris bakpo =》 mobil dng panjang masih dibawah 4 meter, pakai mesin legendaris vios, empuk...

Kalo bisa, cari yang trim S matic

Kenapa?

krn pake keyless,
jok penumpang bisa di geser maju mundur untuk memperluas bagasi tnp melipat jok.
jika butuh lipat rata pun bisa, karena ketika dilipat, jok bagian bawah maju kedpan lalu sandaran joknya terlipat rata lantai. ..

Pelipatan+maju mundur jok penumpang serta keyless ini yg gak ada di trim selain trim S Matic.
sepertinya bisa jadi pertimbangan :big_exellent:
kekuranganya apa ?
Pboyz97
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 4571
Joined: Sun Oct 09, 2016 15:14
Location: East Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: BRV Prestige Non HS 2023 - AN HRV SE 2023

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by Pboyz97 »

kalo dari semua kandidat saya vote splash/ mirage. kalo alternatif bisa lirik yaris bakpao
Past:
'09 GE8
'10 CRV RE
'13 CX5
'17 Xpander
'19 Yaris
'18 CX5
'18 ANF 2GD
'18 HRV
'18 ANKI 2GD
'19 CRV
'14 GNKI 1TR
'22 brio
'18 RX300
'18 ANPS
Now:
'23 voxy
'23 BRV
'23 HRV
Pboyz97
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 4571
Joined: Sun Oct 09, 2016 15:14
Location: East Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: BRV Prestige Non HS 2023 - AN HRV SE 2023

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by Pboyz97 »

supersae wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 7:55
quyquy wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 7:29 Yaris bakpo =》 mobil dng panjang masih dibawah 4 meter, pakai mesin legendaris vios, empuk...

Kalo bisa, cari yang trim S matic

Kenapa?

krn pake keyless,
jok penumpang bisa di geser maju mundur untuk memperluas bagasi tnp melipat jok.
jika butuh lipat rata pun bisa, karena ketika dilipat, jok bagian bawah maju kedpan lalu sandaran joknya terlipat rata lantai. ..

Pelipatan+maju mundur jok penumpang serta keyless ini yg gak ada di trim selain trim S Matic.
sepertinya bisa jadi pertimbangan :big_exellent:
kekuranganya apa ?
saya bantu jawab ya. kebetulan dulu pernah miara selama 4 tahun. kekurangannya ada di driving feel dan handlingnya yg biasa aja. sm tarikan atasnya juga agak kurang walaupun yg generasi yaris bakpao ini putaran bawahnya lumayan ngisi
Past:
'09 GE8
'10 CRV RE
'13 CX5
'17 Xpander
'19 Yaris
'18 CX5
'18 ANF 2GD
'18 HRV
'18 ANKI 2GD
'19 CRV
'14 GNKI 1TR
'22 brio
'18 RX300
'18 ANPS
Now:
'23 voxy
'23 BRV
'23 HRV
mike22
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1431
Joined: Mon Nov 15, 2010 10:28
Daily Vehicle: K24 RM3

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by mike22 »

Livina/x-gear yg pendek mungkin?
Tapi unitnya agak susah sih.
Atau march 1.5 jg mayan.
Tp kl mau yang agak baru sy suggest datsun go live cvt aja, tinggal ganti ban yg bagusan+ganti parts kaki2 nya pake march.
User avatar
XMTdeluxe
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 251
Joined: Fri May 25, 2018 8:18
Location: Bandung
Daily Vehicle: ANT XMT deluxe

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by XMTdeluxe »

supersae wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 1:52 compact car(garasi mepet 3x4) Matic suspensi paling nyaman apa ? dana 150 , yg saya tahu:
Ayla
New picanto 2012 up
Karimum wagon
Splash
Mirage
lainya... ?
Ayla yang 1.2 R, harga baru 150 jt lebih sedikit dpt yg matic, manual lbh murah 12 juta. Dimensi panjang 3,66 meter, lebar 1,60 mtr. Ground clearance 180 mm sama dgn All New Ertiga lho. Keunggulan mutlak dibanding mobil lain, radius putar. Kelewatan cari alamat, puter balik gampang banget.
Jok sdh empuk, lumayan supportif dibanding yg 1000cc.
Kekurangannya posisi nyetir sdh fix, tinggi badan 170 cm ke atas sdh gak enak posisinya. Bantingan suspensi ya nggak empuk kalo dibandingkan reborn 😁
the-mantal
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 526
Joined: Wed Apr 27, 2005 9:47
Location: jakarta

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by the-mantal »

Saran saya ayla krn menurut butt o meter saya empuk. At least bandingannya sama xenia 2022 karakter redamannya lebih enak ayla mnurut saya. Belum pernah pake agya tp harusnya sama ya. Cm getaran mesin nya aja yg a bit annoying
Harta Cinta Tahta!!!
Choose yours
User avatar
josomba
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2916
Joined: Sat Aug 05, 2017 12:00
Location: Tangerang Selatan
Daily Vehicle: Delman

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by josomba »

Kalau march 1.5 masuk opsi sih, bisa diconsider. Bantingan nyaman.

Tp berhubung dia pake mesin hr15de pastikan aja pemilik sebelumnya rutin ganti oli tiap 6 bulan atau cek di balik tutup pengisian oli ada sludge ga.

Kalau 1.2 skip deh, ane dulu piara yg 1.2 agak resek getarannya pas idle.

Splash sbenernya oke juga, tp sebagian orang (mungkin khususnya wanita karena kaki lebih kecil) biasa ga nyaman injak pedalnya, seperti ketinggian dari lantai/dek.
Image
zonepublic
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 584
Joined: Thu Feb 20, 2014 19:08

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by zonepublic »

supersae wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 1:52 compact car(garasi mepet 3x4) Matic suspensi paling nyaman apa ? dana 150 , yg saya tahu:
Ayla
New picanto 2012 up
Karimum wagon
Splash
Mirage
lainya... ?
Irit+dana 150 ya dari pilihan diatas ya mitsu mirage lukot 1:24 dalkot macet parah 1:14 ac on tidak menyiksa diri,cukup nyaman jg sebenernya ignis masuk juga bisa 1:27 lukot tapi maticnya ga smua orang bisa nerima&harus pertamax,klo gue sih seneng krn murah perawatannya matic ignis
Beda sama splash lo ya,klo splash matic masih boros ga bisa tembus 1:20
Diatas 1200 cc pasti ga akan tembus 1:20 lah
HaykelAdityawarman
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 266
Joined: Wed Mar 06, 2019 2:15
Location: Greater Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: 2015 Mitsubishi A03A 3A92 GLX MT

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by HaykelAdityawarman »

supersae wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 1:52 compact car(garasi mepet 3x4) Matic suspensi paling nyaman apa ? dana 150 , yg saya tahu:
Ayla
New picanto 2012 up
Karimum wagon
Splash
Mirage
lainya... ?
Pengalaman pake Mirage 5 tahun. Klo kenyamanan suspensi yang jadi prioritas, dikelas itu paling nyaman March, baru Mirage. Sayang March masih matic konven jadi transmisinya kurang enak dibanding CVT nya Mirage.

Klo mau alternatif saya idem sama yang lain buat ambil Yaris. Secara size mirip2 tapi kenyamanan diatasnya krn memang beda kelas. Tapi layak jadi pertimbangan krn ukurannya mirip city car.
Current: 2008 Mitsubishi CY4A 4B11 CVT

Others:
2020 ANH140 2GD-FTV AT
2019 RU1 L15Z CVT
2019 PQ26-6C 1.2T DSG
2019 CMF-A 1.0 AMT
2013 GM2 L15A AT
2003 E46 M54B25 AT
Pilatypus
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 87
Joined: Sat Jan 01, 2022 15:37

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by Pilatypus »

zonepublic wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 13:01
supersae wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 1:52 compact car(garasi mepet 3x4) Matic suspensi paling nyaman apa ? dana 150 , yg saya tahu:
Ayla
New picanto 2012 up
Karimum wagon
Splash
Mirage
lainya... ?
Irit+dana 150 ya dari pilihan diatas ya mitsu mirage lukot 1:24 dalkot macet parah 1:14 ac on tidak menyiksa diri,cukup nyaman jg sebenernya ignis masuk juga bisa 1:27 lukot tapi maticnya ga smua orang bisa nerima&harus pertamax,klo gue sih seneng krn murah perawatannya matic ignis
Beda sama splash lo ya,klo splash matic masih boros ga bisa tembus 1:20
Diatas 1200 cc pasti ga akan tembus 1:20 lah
Ignis dalkot berapa om?
speedfreak
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 277
Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2007 8:07

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by speedfreak »

Pilatypus wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 22:23
zonepublic wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 13:01
supersae wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 1:52 compact car(garasi mepet 3x4) Matic suspensi paling nyaman apa ? dana 150 , yg saya tahu:
Ayla
New picanto 2012 up
Karimum wagon
Splash
Mirage
lainya... ?
Irit+dana 150 ya dari pilihan diatas ya mitsu mirage lukot 1:24 dalkot macet parah 1:14 ac on tidak menyiksa diri,cukup nyaman jg sebenernya ignis masuk juga bisa 1:27 lukot tapi maticnya ga smua orang bisa nerima&harus pertamax,klo gue sih seneng krn murah perawatannya matic ignis
Beda sama splash lo ya,klo splash matic masih boros ga bisa tembus 1:20
Diatas 1200 cc pasti ga akan tembus 1:20 lah
Ignis dalkot berapa om?
Ignis saya GX AGS dalkot pertamax 1:15 lebih di MID.
Dah gak pernah ngitung konsumsi bensin actual full to full lagi karena sudah ngerasa irit.
Bantingan original ignis keras.
Setelah diganti per jadi mendingan lebih dewasa bantingannya, apalagi setelah diganti merk ban dan juga ukuran ban yang lebarnya naik dari 175 ke 185 juga membantu jadi lebih empuk.

Pernah miara march 1,2 manual dari 2010-2015 juga cukup nyaman suspensi mobilnya dibanding sebelumnya pakai jazz GD3 itu lebih keras.
Pernah minjam yaris bakpao punya teman juga nyaman dinaekinnya.
zonepublic
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 584
Joined: Thu Feb 20, 2014 19:08

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by zonepublic »

Pilatypus wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 22:23
zonepublic wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 13:01
supersae wrote: Sat Aug 27, 2022 1:52 compact car(garasi mepet 3x4) Matic suspensi paling nyaman apa ? dana 150 , yg saya tahu:
Ayla
New picanto 2012 up
Karimum wagon
Splash
Mirage
lainya... ?
Irit+dana 150 ya dari pilihan diatas ya mitsu mirage lukot 1:24 dalkot macet parah 1:14 ac on tidak menyiksa diri,cukup nyaman jg sebenernya ignis masuk juga bisa 1:27 lukot tapi maticnya ga smua orang bisa nerima&harus pertamax,klo gue sih seneng krn murah perawatannya matic ignis
Beda sama splash lo ya,klo splash matic masih boros ga bisa tembus 1:20
Diatas 1200 cc pasti ga akan tembus 1:20 lah
Ignis dalkot berapa om?
Ignis ags bisa 1:15-18 klo lancar
Klo macet 1:12-14
t105erd
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1116
Joined: Sun Mar 20, 2022 1:17

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by t105erd »

Beli baru aja Honda Brio S, siapa tau dapet diskon nanti akhir tahun.
Atau 2nd tahun muda Ignis, kalo jarang bawa penumpang picanto juga enak atau Hyundai i10. Kalo mau yg kelas diatasnya ya Yaris/Livina/SX4/March
kunaskun
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3964
Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2007 8:16

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by kunaskun »

yaris bakpao atau march, bakpao sedikit diatas march. tapi keduanya tetap jauh lebih baik dari sirion, mirage yang satu zaman.
timbermaniac123
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 577
Joined: Wed Sep 18, 2019 16:52
Location: Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: Voxy

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by timbermaniac123 »

t105erd wrote: Sun Aug 28, 2022 7:41 Beli baru aja Honda Brio S, siapa tau dapet diskon nanti akhir tahun.
Atau 2nd tahun muda Ignis, kalo jarang bawa penumpang picanto juga enak atau Hyundai i10. Kalo mau yg kelas diatasnya ya Yaris/Livina/SX4/March
Nah ini bisa juga. Tunggu dealer jual nik lama, mungkin bisa disc lebihan. siapa tau ada bonus seperti garansi 4 tahun sparepart + 5 tahun service. Jadi enak tinggal isi bensin ga pusing ganti oli dll. Kalau mobil second biasa si pr nya ganti aki, roda
impactful
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 446
Joined: Tue Jan 09, 2018 1:09
Location: Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: 2023 27 kWh powerbank on a wheel

Re: Compact / city car nyaman

Post by impactful »

Brio satya e cvt baru surprisingly suspensi cukup nyaman, so far baru pakai 16 hari... Jauh lebih nyaman dari Agya / Ayla bantingannya walau GC nya nggak tinggi2 amat, di garasi juga nggak makan banyak space, cobain full tol ketemu tol eco driving tembus di atas 1:23, ugal mode S masih 1:17
dalkot 1:13 pake pertamax
1x1 XM 2023 | 1 Speed Direct Drive 26.7 kWh