Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Ingin membahas hal-hal umum mengenai mobil dan otomotif, silakan bahas disini...

Moderators: r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze, akbarfit, Ryan Steele, sh00t

User avatar
JESKONENG
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 4362
Joined: Sat Apr 21, 2007 12:40

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by JESKONENG »

matic DSG di VW / Audi sih asyik2 aja pastinya
Norival Fuel Enhancer
Gold, Platinum, Diesel, DRAG SERIES & Oil Enhancer
FB (id : Torry Parantoro)
hp/WA : 081328516999
hariy
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2269
Joined: Sun Sep 08, 2013 1:03
Location: 06º 35' 42" LS 110º 40' 18" BT

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by hariy »

pilih 22nya. mobil pertama / sehari2 matic, yg buat wiken manual...ngga usah yg mahal2, kelas jes (under 2013) s.d innova (under 2010)...
User avatar
imingwahyudi
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2972
Joined: Sat Nov 30, 2013 15:30
Location: 万隆, 印度尼西亚

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by imingwahyudi »

Errrrrr,

Kalo manualnya long throw sama kopling keras dudul, pasti milih auto

Kalo autonya bloon ga ketolongan, pasti milih manual :big_childish:


Pilih manual aja deh :mky_02: , lumayan itung itung CelFit pindah ke mobil pas macet macetan di jalan :mky_03: :big_grin:
User avatar
ovation
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 64
Joined: Thu May 22, 2014 2:58

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by ovation »

imingwahyudi wrote:Errrrrr,

Kalo manualnya long throw sama kopling keras dudul, pasti milih auto

Kalo autonya bloon ga ketolongan, pasti milih manual :big_childish:


Pilih manual aja deh :mky_02: , lumayan itung itung CelFit pindah ke mobil pas macet macetan di jalan :mky_03: :big_grin:

CelFit? Lha ini kaki kiri doang yg jadi kekar om? #anejugapakeMT

:ngacir:
User avatar
imingwahyudi
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2972
Joined: Sat Nov 30, 2013 15:30
Location: 万隆, 印度尼西亚

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by imingwahyudi »

ovation wrote:
imingwahyudi wrote:Errrrrr,

Kalo manualnya long throw sama kopling keras dudul, pasti milih auto

Kalo autonya bloon ga ketolongan, pasti milih manual :big_childish:


Pilih manual aja deh :mky_02: , lumayan itung itung CelFit pindah ke mobil pas macet macetan di jalan :mky_03: :big_grin:

CelFit? Lha ini kaki kiri doang yg jadi kekar om? #anejugapakeMT

:ngacir:
Tangan kiri juga kekar si :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03:

*ngikutin metode MazdaSutra :big_grin: :ngacir: :ngacir: :ngacir: :ngacir: *
User avatar
loadeddiapers
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 257
Joined: Fri Jan 24, 2014 5:06

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by loadeddiapers »

imingwahyudi wrote:Errrrrr,

Kalo manualnya long throw sama kopling keras dudul, pasti milih auto

Kalo autonya bloon ga ketolongan, pasti milih manual :big_childish:
Makanya mobil saya sekarang 1 A/T 1 M/T :mky_02:
Image
User avatar
nescafe
Member of Mechanic Master
Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 14333
Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 3:18
Location: jakarta

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by nescafe »

hmmm tergantung mobilnya apa dulu kali ya kalau gw.. heheheh :D
Permisii :ungg: ............................. :ngacir:
TUFF Stough
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3515
Joined: Tue Nov 29, 2005 5:44
Daily Vehicle: Ipin - Ipah

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by TUFF Stough »

Tiptronik mengakomodasi keduanya. :big_peace:
User avatar
radinalakbar7
New Member of Senior Mechanic
New Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 158
Joined: Thu Nov 21, 2013 12:23

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by radinalakbar7 »

PenyuTurbo wrote:Bros semua,

Gejala semakin macetnya di kota-kota besar dan perkembangan teknologi transmisi Kendaraan Bermotor ... maka mana yang lebih disukai ... Transmisi Automatic (MATIC) atau MANUAL ? dan apa yang melatar belakangi pilihan anda ?
Sesuai kebutuhan saja pak, kalo di kota besar matic lebih "manusiawi"
Manual cocoknya di kota yg non macet.

real man bukan use three pedal or rich man only use two pedal. Tapi real man buy their own car with their own money.
Jman
New Member of Senior Mechanic
New Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 157
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2012 9:37

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by Jman »

Bro, gw pake crv gen 4 mt..

Sebenarnya karakteristik mobil manual sama semua ya?
Dari keluarga gw beli swift rush crv, kok sedut" jalannya..
Klo macet gk enak, apa memang gtu semua ya?

Mobil matic katanya kalo buat ngerem sedut"? Bener gk ya?
User avatar
amfibi
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8594
Joined: Mon Dec 31, 2012 5:45
Location: Central Park, JakBar

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by amfibi »

Jman wrote:Bro, gw pake crv gen 4 mt..

Sebenarnya karakteristik mobil manual sama semua ya?
Dari keluarga gw beli swift rush crv, kok sedut" jalannya..
Klo macet gk enak, apa memang gtu semua ya?

Mobil matic katanya kalo buat ngerem sedut"? Bener gk ya?
Matic ga ada "sedut2 kok om, pas ngerem jg...
Jman
New Member of Senior Mechanic
New Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 157
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2012 9:37

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by Jman »

amfibi wrote:
Jman wrote:Bro, gw pake crv gen 4 mt..

Sebenarnya karakteristik mobil manual sama semua ya?
Dari keluarga gw beli swift rush crv, kok sedut" jalannya..
Klo macet gk enak, apa memang gtu semua ya?

Mobil matic katanya kalo buat ngerem sedut"? Bener gk ya?
Matic ga ada "sedut2 kok om, pas ngerem jg...
Temen punya vios matic, katanya kalo pas macet.. Ngeremnya tuhh sedut" bro..

Klo manual gw pas gas sedut"..

Mobil matic transmisinya lancar kan ya?
Blm pernah coba bawa matic, kalo naik pernah :D

Rencana tahun depan mw tuker nihh, betis lumayan juga dijakarta pagi siang sore malam macet ahaha..
User avatar
WongZo
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2083
Joined: Tue Dec 17, 2013 15:06
Location: Bandung

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by WongZo »

Jman wrote:Bro, gw pake crv gen 4 mt..

Sebenarnya karakteristik mobil manual sama semua ya?
Dari keluarga gw beli swift rush crv, kok sedut" jalannya..
Klo macet gk enak, apa memang gtu semua ya?

Mobil matic katanya kalo buat ngerem sedut"? Bener gk ya?
Klw angkat kopling krng pas yh sedut" gtu, atau udh lama ga diservis atau bbm jelek pengaruh jg :big_smile]
User avatar
amfibi
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8594
Joined: Mon Dec 31, 2012 5:45
Location: Central Park, JakBar

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by amfibi »

Jman wrote:
amfibi wrote:
Jman wrote:Bro, gw pake crv gen 4 mt..

Sebenarnya karakteristik mobil manual sama semua ya?
Dari keluarga gw beli swift rush crv, kok sedut" jalannya..
Klo macet gk enak, apa memang gtu semua ya?

Mobil matic katanya kalo buat ngerem sedut"? Bener gk ya?
Matic ga ada "sedut2 kok om, pas ngerem jg...
Temen punya vios matic, katanya kalo pas macet.. Ngeremnya tuhh sedut" bro..

Klo manual gw pas gas sedut"..

Mobil matic transmisinya lancar kan ya?
Blm pernah coba bawa matic, kalo naik pernah :D

Rencana tahun depan mw tuker nihh, betis lumayan juga dijakarta pagi siang sore malam macet ahaha..
Selama ane bawa mobil matic, ga ada tuh yg sedut2... :upss:

Lancar kok, enak dipake kalo buat daily jkt mah...

Kecuali buat weekend warrior/pakean di daerah minim macet, mending pake manual aja :mky_01:
hariy
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2269
Joined: Sun Sep 08, 2013 1:03
Location: 06º 35' 42" LS 110º 40' 18" BT

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by hariy »

sedut2 ato ndut2an kalo pas macet, emang begitu adanya...waktu pedal gas diangkat, ECU di injeksi ato karburator langsung stop bbm...jadi waktu pedal gas dilepas sejenak, lalu di gas lagi, ada semacam lag..kalo matic ngga begitu terasa, kan rpm nya lebih tinggi dikit daripada manual, buktinya matic mau berhenti, kaki kita nahan remnya butuh usaha lebih biar ngga ngeloyor....IMALY.
User avatar
amfibi
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8594
Joined: Mon Dec 31, 2012 5:45
Location: Central Park, JakBar

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by amfibi »

hariy wrote:sedut2 ato ndut2an kalo pas macet, emang begitu adanya...waktu pedal gas diangkat, ECU di injeksi ato karburator langsung stop bbm...jadi waktu pedal gas dilepas sejenak, lalu di gas lagi, ada semacam lag..kalo matic ngga begitu terasa, kan rpm nya lebih tinggi dikit daripada manual, buktinya matic mau berhenti, kaki kita nahan remnya butuh usaha lebih biar ngga ngeloyor....IMALY.
Yup betul... :mky_01:
Jman
New Member of Senior Mechanic
New Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 157
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2012 9:37

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by Jman »

Bbm pake super shell, service rutin tuhh..
Emang karakteristiknya begitu, biar irit kyknya..
hariy wrote:sedut2 ato ndut2an kalo pas macet, emang begitu adanya...waktu pedal gas diangkat, ECU di injeksi ato karburator langsung stop bbm...jadi waktu pedal gas dilepas sejenak, lalu di gas lagi, ada semacam lag..kalo matic ngga begitu terasa, kan rpm nya lebih tinggi dikit daripada manual, buktinya matic mau berhenti, kaki kita nahan remnya butuh usaha lebih biar ngga ngeloyor....IMALY.
Iya kyk gtu bro, kalo macet udh kyk dugem mobil gw wakakaka.. Pegel juga..
Bisa diakalin gk bro? Biar gk sedut" gtu..
Udh coba stel di beres, msh sama aja..
hariy
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2269
Joined: Sun Sep 08, 2013 1:03
Location: 06º 35' 42" LS 110º 40' 18" BT

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by hariy »

waduh...kalo setau saya, ngga bisa di seting tuh...apalagi mobil2 sekarang sensi sama kata IRIT. jadinya mesin cc kecil masih dipaksa irit lagi...jadi kurang nyaman buat bermacet ria/stop-go-stop...beda kalo mesinnya 1.8 ke atas, biasanya lebih smooth...
Jman
New Member of Senior Mechanic
New Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 157
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2012 9:37

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by Jman »

hariy wrote:waduh...kalo setau saya, ngga bisa di seting tuh...apalagi mobil2 sekarang sensi sama kata IRIT. jadinya mesin cc kecil masih dipaksa irit lagi...jadi kurang nyaman buat bermacet ria/stop-go-stop...beda kalo mesinnya 1.8 ke atas, biasanya lebih smooth...
Ohh jd semakin kecil ccnya, sedut"nya lebih parah ya..
Punya gw dulu swift rush, sekarang crv 2.0cc kirain yg crv gk sedut" ternyata sama aja ya..
Pantesan sekarang bnyk yg beli matic ya, mungkin gara" itu..
User avatar
ibar78
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1292
Joined: Sat Aug 04, 2007 11:06
Location: mtg, jakarta
Daily Vehicle: toyota fans boys

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by ibar78 »

TERNYATA MATIK ENAK JUGA....disopirin ma temen gw... :wkkk:
:popcorn:
hariy
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2269
Joined: Sun Sep 08, 2013 1:03
Location: 06º 35' 42" LS 110º 40' 18" BT

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by hariy »

Jman wrote:Ohh jd semakin kecil ccnya, sedut"nya lebih parah ya..
Punya gw dulu swift rush, sekarang crv 2.0cc kirain yg crv gk sedut" ternyata sama aja ya..
Pantesan sekarang bnyk yg beli matic ya, mungkin gara" itu..
yah, itu sih subyektif saya saja yg awam ini...tapi kalo mau yg beda signifikan, sebaiknya membandingkan enjin 2.4 ato 2.7 dengan enjin 1.5...
lha kalo matic, rpm memang diset dari ECU lebih tinggi dikiiiit ketimbang manual, engine brake juga ngga segalak manual...cmiiw. :big_smile]
Jman
New Member of Senior Mechanic
New Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 157
Joined: Fri Sep 14, 2012 9:37

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by Jman »

hariy wrote:
Jman wrote:Ohh jd semakin kecil ccnya, sedut"nya lebih parah ya..
Punya gw dulu swift rush, sekarang crv 2.0cc kirain yg crv gk sedut" ternyata sama aja ya..
Pantesan sekarang bnyk yg beli matic ya, mungkin gara" itu..
yah, itu sih subyektif saya saja yg awam ini...tapi kalo mau yg beda signifikan, sebaiknya membandingkan enjin 2.4 ato 2.7 dengan enjin 1.5...
lha kalo matic, rpm memang diset dari ECU lebih tinggi dikiiiit ketimbang manual, engine brake juga ngga segalak manual...cmiiw. :big_smile]
Kalo anda saja awam gimana gw bro, wakaka..
Tq ya infonya..

Kapan" coba test drive mobil matic ahh :D
hariy
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2269
Joined: Sun Sep 08, 2013 1:03
Location: 06º 35' 42" LS 110º 40' 18" BT

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by hariy »

Jman wrote:Kalo anda saja awam gimana gw bro, wakaka..
Tq ya infonya..

Kapan" coba test drive mobil matic ahh :D
ah, orang2 macam saya bagaimanapun juga tetap awam koq, om...masih banyak langit di atas langit. ya, baiknya td mobil baik manual maupun matic sebelum beli, lagipula tiap diler mobil sudah menyediakan unit buat td.....
Rizu21
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 177
Joined: Mon May 12, 2014 12:02

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by Rizu21 »

Iya om..kadang gejala nyendut2 bisa jadi kendala di jalan macet..

Makax bnyak pke matik djakarta karena klo macet nggantung kopling...capekx luar biasa..=.=
User avatar
ibar78
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1292
Joined: Sat Aug 04, 2007 11:06
Location: mtg, jakarta
Daily Vehicle: toyota fans boys

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by ibar78 »

Rizu21 wrote:Iya om..kadang gejala nyendut2 bisa jadi kendala di jalan macet..

Makax bnyak pke matik djakarta karena klo macet nggantung kopling...capekx luar biasa..=.=

masa matik gahar masih ndut2an....matik apaan tuh.....gw kira ndut2an gejalanya xenia doang.... :wkkk:
:popcorn: