Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Ingin membahas hal-hal umum mengenai mobil dan otomotif, silakan bahas disini...

Moderators: r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze, akbarfit, Ryan Steele, sh00t

Pboyz97
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 4977
Joined: Sun Oct 09, 2016 15:14
Location: East Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: BRV Prestige Non HS 2023 - AN HRV SE 2023

Re: mobil matic vs mobil manual

Post by Pboyz97 »

Tergantung jenis mobilnya & kebutuhan om, kalo om tinggal kota / provinsi yang cukup jarang kendaraan manual lebih baik, soalnya harga & biaya perawatannya lebih murah dibanding matic + peformanya lebih baik juga. Kalo om TS tinggal di kota besar yang macet, matic lebih baik soalnya ga bikin kaki kiri pegel hehehe. Kalo jenis mobil menurut saya, LCGC / LMPV manual lebih baik, tapi kalo mobil diatasnya (citycar, hatch dll) matic lebih baik.
Past:
'09 GE8
'10 CRV RE
'13 CX5
'17 Xpander
'19 Yaris
'18 CX5
'18 ANF 2GD
'18 HRV
'18 ANKI 2GD
'19 CRV
'14 GNKI 1TR
'22 brio
'18 RX300
'18 ANPS
Now:
'23 voxy
'23 BRV
'23 HRV
'24 U11
Stygulator
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 273
Joined: Thu Aug 13, 2015 14:33

Re: mobil matic vs mobil manual

Post by Stygulator »

Suda dijawab oleh atas ane.
Tambahan, kebanyakan mobil matic di indo (gak semua) punya fitur lebi lengkap ketimbang sodara manualny. Ntah kenapa klo di Indo mobil matic lebi dijunjung oleh ATPM. Varian tertinggi suatu mobil biasany cuman tersedia A/T :big_slap:
User avatar
ChZ
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 16794
Joined: Tue Oct 08, 2013 14:30
Location: Semarang
Daily Vehicle: Civic FK4

Re: mobil matic vs mobil manual

Post by ChZ »

Bagus mana? Dua duanya bagus.

Liat kegunaan.


Sent from my 2014817 using Seraya Motor mobile app
1997 E39 M52B28
2017 FK4 L15B7
doge
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 805
Joined: Mon Jan 18, 2016 14:54

Re: mobil matic vs mobil manual

Post by doge »

Konteks pertanyaan tdk jelas.

Bagus dlm hal apa?
Teknologi?
Kepraktisan operasional?
Kehematan bbm?
Kemudahan perbaikan?
Hal subjektif (fun to drive etc)?
:ngacir:
User avatar
iwidiyanto
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 624
Joined: Sun Oct 30, 2011 11:48
Location: Antar Kota Antar Propinsi

Re: mobil matic vs mobil manual

Post by iwidiyanto »

Kok saya jadi inget acaranya Pak Tino Sidin di TVRI
User avatar
andyez86
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 928
Joined: Sat May 21, 2016 12:08
Location: Solo
Daily Vehicle: Innova

Re: mobil matic vs mobil manual

Post by andyez86 »

Klo maticnya macam dual clutch gt ya mending matic....klo matic nya ngga jedug ya mending matic....
cursQ
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 680
Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2016 17:51

Re: mobil matic vs mobil manual

Post by cursQ »

Wah pertanyaannya luas banget.. dari segi apa nya hehe..
Klo buat saya yg sering habis waktu di jalanan sih fix matic.. mau saya pake city car miras tahun muda atau e36 tahun tua sekalipun matic ttp lebih enak drpd saya pake avanza manual.. tp untuk luar kota saya prefer veloz manual saya selain besar tinggi ya manual lebih enak untuk luar kota.. imho..
hamidadzan
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 45
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2017 5:41

Re: mobil matic vs mobil manual

Post by hamidadzan »

Bingung beli mobil , saya punya bajet 160 , mobil second yg bagus nyaman dipake dan model yg tdk kemkan jaman sama awet
ak4ng
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 10473
Joined: Sun Aug 15, 2010 7:20
Location: smi, bdg, jawa barat
Daily Vehicle: Unimog

Re: mobil matic vs mobil manual

Post by ak4ng »

Metik single clutch kelaot.... cvt gud for dalkot.... manual for lukot... dsg/dct gosong kemana2...
REAR-WHEEL DRIVE TO KEEP YOU MOVING FORWARD

INFO KOPI KLIK: KOPI MALABAR
User avatar
paidjho
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1210
Joined: Tue Jan 05, 2016 0:58
Location: Jakarta

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by paidjho »

Baca baca Dsg wet lebih baik drpd dry.
hohaa9
Visitor
Visitor
Posts: 9
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2017 2:51

Re: mobil matic vs mobil manual

Post by hohaa9 »

hamidadzan wrote:Bingung beli mobil , saya punya bajet 160 , mobil second yg bagus nyaman dipake dan model yg tdk kemkan jaman sama awet
GL gan, ane budgetnya jg mirip2 agan, mau ambil second GL manual, klo ambil baru, GL matic. Hehehe. Kebanyakan baca review jd bingung matic ama manual. Jd bc2 trit di mari. Secara ane cuma muter2 sby malang pasuruan dan kota sekitarnya... Kalo di jkt/bdg wajib matic.
Or4cle
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1316
Joined: Wed Nov 02, 2016 1:59

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by Or4cle »

Tergantung dari statusnya ... kalau single, in relationship atau type Don Juan pasti memilih matic. Alasannya, tangan kiri lebih leluasa "berpetualang"

Untuk saat ini pilihannya manual, karena masa itu telah lewat ...
pernahmiskin
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 677
Joined: Tue Apr 19, 2016 5:48
Location: jogja, blitar, jakarta

Re: mobil matic vs mobil manual

Post by pernahmiskin »

Dulu sy antipati banget pakai matic, gegara asam urat di kaki kiri, akhirnya bungkus fortuner matic sekitar tahun 2010 sampai dgn skrg pun biarpun asam urat sudah jarang kambuh (amit2 kambuh lg) sy wes males mbalek manual...walaupun jg sdh ganti mobil lainnya



hamidadzan wrote:Bingung beli mobil , saya punya bajet 160 , mobil second yg bagus nyaman dipake dan model yg tdk kemkan jaman sama awet
Tambahin budget dikit om, dpt innova diesel matic tahun 2011.
Jawaban dr pertanyaan om ada di innova diesel matic..
:big_exellent:
Jangan menghina kalau masih bisa di hina
Jangan merendahkan kalau masih bisa di rendahkan
Jangan sok kaya, kalau masih punya hutang
:big_exellent:
noenk
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 61
Joined: Fri Feb 05, 2016 2:18

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by noenk »

Dulu pernah takut beli matik kuatir gk kuat nanjak n lemot... Skg pake matik diesel ternyata sangat nyaman n mantap, luar kota naek gunung n nyalip2 bis aja ternyata gk kedodoran.. Kayaknya solarnya jg lbh irit lombok jogja isi 220rb.. Sp jogja isi 200rb sdh full lg.. Kl di mid sih dpt 16,6
noenk
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 61
Joined: Fri Feb 05, 2016 2:18

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by noenk »

Dulu pernah takut beli matik kuatir gk kuat nanjak n lemot... Skg pake matik diesel ternyata sangat nyaman n mantap, luar kota naek gunung n nyalip2 bis aja ternyata gk kedodoran.. Kayaknya solarnya jg lbh irit lombok jogja isi 220rb.. Sp jogja isi 200rb sdh full lg.. Kl di mid sih dpt 16,6
Ichtyophile
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 207
Joined: Mon Aug 08, 2016 16:32

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by Ichtyophile »

Anak Jakarta, ya pilih matic lah...nasib..nasib
dimzis
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 66
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2016 9:23

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by dimzis »

Matic nanjak lemot? nggak kebukti sama pengalaman libur tahun baru kemarin..coba jlan ke Guci Tegal..jalannya naik terjal dan belok tajam ditambah antri karena macet, mobil manual dari mulai avanza, kisul sampai colt diesel pada gak kuat nanjak n gak pintar main setengah kopling alhasil pada berasap koplingnya berhenti di tengah2 tanjakan, sementara ane pake avanza matic bisa nanjak sampe parkiran paling atas tanpa masalah :big_okay:
kompresorz
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 5628
Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2012 4:58

Re: Pilih Mana Transmisi MATIC atau MANUAL

Post by kompresorz »

Kalo mobil terbaru cc kecil ky jaz hrv saya tetap pilih manual..biar tetap berasa tenaganya...enak buat main redline

Honda pedal kopling jg sangat ringan..gak berasa cape