ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Butuh saran untuk membeli kendaraan untuk pribadi, keluarga ataupun kerja? Silakan dibahas disini...

Moderators: Ryan Steele, sh00t, r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze, akbarfit

pinan6
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2012 15:22

ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by pinan6 »

salam kenal semua para Master SM
saya lagi bingung nih mau ganti mobil xtail xt 2008 cvt
pilihan nya antara nissan murano 2010 2.5l 2nd ( IU pastinya) dgn harga 2nd 500jt-an
atau mazda cx 5 touring?

kabarnya keduanya memiliki fitur2 yg cukup asik, kenyamanan, dan handling yg baik
namun ada kendala dari pilihan diatas, contohnya
cx5 memiliki ruangan yg lbh sempit ( legroom maupun headroom baris kedua)
murano kabarnya spacious, hanya saja di daerah kami (sumut) susah didapat, kalaupun dapat, pasti susah jual kembali, dan sparepart yg susah juga kabarnya

adapun jalan yg kita tempuh biasaya jalan lintas luarkota berjarak 50km.

jadi rada2 bingnung nih. tolong ya para Master SM atas penerangannya
apa salah kelebihan kekurangan dr keduanya, baik dari segi fitur, kenyamanan, handling dan lain sebagainya
terima kasih sebelumnya
User avatar
Hansen
Member of Mechanic Master
Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 16497
Joined: Tue Apr 03, 2007 14:24

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by Hansen »

sebelumnya kalo boleh tau kendala apa yg membuat bro ingin mengganti mobil yg skrg?

murano 2010 yg dimaksud itu apakah yg modelnya sudah seperti ini?

Image
Image
MonSTER_GTR
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2494
Joined: Sun Sep 30, 2012 11:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by MonSTER_GTR »

wah perbandingannya nih mobil super irit (cx-5) vs mobil boros banget (murano)
Here Come's The Best Car - Coming soon
pinan6
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2012 15:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by pinan6 »

Hansen wrote:sebelumnya kalo boleh tau kendala apa yg membuat bro ingin mengganti mobil yg skrg?

murano 2010 yg dimaksud itu apakah yg modelnya sudah seperti ini?

Image
betul sekali

mobil yg skrg sebenarnya cukup nyaman, hanya saja ada beberapa hal yg kurang menurut saya, misalnya
kabin yg bising, apalagi dikecepatan tinggi, suara ban lbh besar dr suara audio saya
kabin nya terasa berayun2 apabila dikecepatan tinggi dan limbung saat belokan dikecepatan tinggi
baris kedua yg slalu dikeluhkan oleh istri saya ,yg berbadan agak besar, sangat kurang lapang
dan yg terakhir. model rasanya agak tua dan fitur terasa kurang lengkap, hehehhe
pinan6
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2012 15:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by pinan6 »

MonSTER_GTR wrote:wah perbandingannya nih mobil super irit (cx-5) vs mobil boros banget (murano)
murano yg 2500 aja, jangan 3500 ( ga tahan, kantong terbakar)
hahahhahah :wkkk:
User avatar
Hansen
Member of Mechanic Master
Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 16497
Joined: Tue Apr 03, 2007 14:24

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by Hansen »

pinan6 wrote:
MonSTER_GTR wrote:wah perbandingannya nih mobil super irit (cx-5) vs mobil boros banget (murano)
murano yg 2500 aja, jangan 3500 ( ga tahan, kantong terbakar)
hahahhahah :wkkk:
mesin 2.5L nya sama gak sih dengan mobil yg skrg? :e-think:
Image
pinan6
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2012 15:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by pinan6 »

Hansen wrote:
pinan6 wrote:
MonSTER_GTR wrote:wah perbandingannya nih mobil super irit (cx-5) vs mobil boros banget (murano)
murano yg 2500 aja, jangan 3500 ( ga tahan, kantong terbakar)
hahahhahah :wkkk:
mesin 2.5L nya sama gak sih dengan mobil yg skrg? :e-think:
seharusnya sih sama
dgn transmisi yg sama juga cvt
unlimited90
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 84
Joined: Mon Mar 12, 2012 3:08

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by unlimited90 »

+1 for cx5. Dgn hrg segitu sdh bisa dpt mobil baru, technology baru, plus mobil aman dan irit. Kalo utk murano sendiri mobil krg laris, masih bagusan jauh Rx, cuma harganya maahaaaal. Kalo cx5 utk maintainance aman karena dealer resmi sudah ada di banyak kota kota besar.
pinan6
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2012 15:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by pinan6 »

unlimited90 wrote:+1 for cx5. Dgn hrg segitu sdh bisa dpt mobil baru, technology baru, plus mobil aman dan irit. Kalo utk murano sendiri mobil krg laris, masih bagusan jauh Rx, cuma harganya maahaaaal. Kalo cx5 utk maintainance aman karena dealer resmi sudah ada di banyak kota kota besar.
maunya si rx270, cuman dana ga kesampean
MonSTER_GTR
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2494
Joined: Sun Sep 30, 2012 11:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by MonSTER_GTR »

yang 2.5 kayaknya bakal loyo deh, secara bodinya gambot, power to weight ratio nya gak imbang ujung2 nya boros bensin juga. kalo gak salah murano belum dipasang turbo kan?
Here Come's The Best Car - Coming soon
pinan6
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2012 15:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by pinan6 »

MonSTER_GTR wrote:yang 2.5 kayaknya bakal loyo deh, secara bodinya gambot, power to weight ratio nya gak imbang ujung2 nya boros bensin juga. kalo gak salah murano belum dipasang turbo kan?
belum pake turbo, sama persis seperti xtrail
hanya saja sudah awd setau saya
MonSTER_GTR
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2494
Joined: Sun Sep 30, 2012 11:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by MonSTER_GTR »

kalo ane bilang sih mending minang cx-5, tapi kalo murano aj kesempitan apalagi cx-5 ya, gak mau berpaling ke MPV aj :mky_01:
Here Come's The Best Car - Coming soon
pinan6
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2012 15:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by pinan6 »

MonSTER_GTR wrote:kalo ane bilang sih mending minang cx-5, tapi kalo murano aj kesempitan apalagi cx-5 ya, gak mau berpaling ke MPV aj :mky_01:
murano masi blm tau sempit atau tidak, belum pernah rasain
yg jelas kalo xtrail yg kerasa sempit dibaris kedua
MonSTER_GTR
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2494
Joined: Sun Sep 30, 2012 11:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by MonSTER_GTR »

yaaahhh nih kelebihan murano :
-interior build quality nya lebih bagus dari cx-5, tapi bukanya cx-5 build quality nya jelek loh
-bodinya gagah, tampang ganteng (opini pribadi)
-interior enak dipandang karena warnanya beige
-fitur bejibun
-sun roof 2 biji depan belakang
-illuminated interior (wah kesanya mewah banget tuh)
-electric seat with memory

kekurangan :
-yang 2.5 mesinya boyo, mengigat bodinya yang besar
-matic nya konvensional
-perawatan mahal
-bensin boros

maaf kalo ada yang salah hhe
sebetulnya sih lawanya murano ini kan CX-7, kenapa gak coba liat2 aj CX-7 bekas kan harganya udah dibawah 500 an
Here Come's The Best Car - Coming soon
pinan6
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2012 15:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by pinan6 »

MonSTER_GTR wrote:yaaahhh nih kelebihan murano :
-interior build quality nya lebih bagus dari cx-5, tapi bukanya cx-5 build quality nya jelek loh
-bodinya gagah, tampang ganteng (opini pribadi)
-interior enak dipandang karena warnanya beige
-fitur bejibun
-sun roof 2 biji depan belakang
-illuminated interior (wah kesanya mewah banget tuh)
-electric seat with memory

kekurangan :
-yang 2.5 mesinya boyo, mengigat bodinya yang besar
-matic nya konvensional
-perawatan mahal
-bensin boros

maaf kalo ada yang salah hhe
sebetulnya sih lawanya murano ini kan CX-7, kenapa gak coba liat2 aj CX-7 bekas kan harganya udah dibawah 500 an
thanks atas masukannya bro
cx-7 kesan interior kyknya kurang mewah menurut saya, bahannya keras2 (pernah numpang duduk sekali punya temen)
dan bantingan juga agak keras kabarnya, jadi kurang berminat nih

utk murano 2010 transmisi seharusnya sudah cvt hanya belum ada manualnya
ronaldwij
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 35
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2012 15:40

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by ronaldwij »

Vote cx 5., reason : model baru,mobil baru, dan ane jg baru ambil tuh unit
User avatar
campoeran
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2782
Joined: Thu Oct 17, 2002 10:44
Location: surabaya rek

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by campoeran »

Murano 2.5 L di atpm ada ? brp duit ? atau IU ya ?

kl sama2 2.5 rasanya mending ke cx5 deh . Itu murano gambot dikasih 2.5L dijamin lemot .
Kl kuat 3.5 ya mendingan murano deh .
pinan6
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2012 15:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by pinan6 »

ronaldwij wrote:Vote cx 5., reason : model baru,mobil baru, dan ane jg baru ambil tuh unit
kalo boleh tau, cx5 baris keduanya sama besar dgn xtrail ga?
atau lbh besar atau lebih kecil
campoeran wrote:Murano 2.5 L di atpm ada ? brp duit ? atau IU ya ?

kl sama2 2.5 rasanya mending ke cx5 deh . Itu murano gambot dikasih 2.5L dijamin lemot .
Kl kuat 3.5 ya mendingan murano deh .
atpm hanya ada 3500 otr jakarta 750jt. 2500 hanya via IU harga kita cek di website2 sktr 780jt otr jakarta
kalo yg 3,5L, kita ga kuat ama minyaknya nih. pasti kerasa banget. jadi ngincar yg 2.5L aja
kabarnya murano lbh spacious. memang body lbh besar, jadi kita cari space juga nih
User avatar
F-man10
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 244
Joined: Wed Jun 20, 2012 3:32

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by F-man10 »

vote for CX5, alternatif lain harier :mky_01:
User avatar
Turboman
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 22001
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 5:14

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by Turboman »

Soal Murano.........udah pernah ngecek harga spare parts Murano belommm ya ?

Clue : kenapa mobil ini sangat jarang di jalan

Tanya kenapa ? :mrgreen:
* Bukan ajakan Beli *
User avatar
grandscenic
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1490
Joined: Wed Dec 23, 2009 4:16

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by grandscenic »

jangan jangan ga ada yg cocok larinya crv lg, mengingat TSnya pengen kabin yg luas
Etme Bulma Dünyası
User avatar
evolution21
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 5884
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 10:32

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by evolution21 »

um turbo, kalopun murano memang harga sparepartnya tidak bersahabat di kantong
tp kayanya bukan tipikal orang indo deh sebelum beli mobil ngecek harga sparepart dulu.

ada alasan lain dr kurang lakunya murano ini
User avatar
Turboman
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 22001
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 5:14

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by Turboman »

evolution21 wrote:um turbo, kalopun murano memang harga sparepartnya tidak bersahabat di kantong
tp kayanya bukan tipikal orang indo deh sebelum beli mobil ngecek harga sparepart dulu.

ada alasan lain dr kurang lakunya murano ini
betul, mungkin saja karena "word of mouth" dr para pemilik yg testi

skg kita lihat saja di IU, berapa banyak IU yg nyetok Murano dibanding Harrier :mrgreen:

Kalo sebab2 lain kurang paham juga

CMIIW
* Bukan ajakan Beli *
User avatar
andy1800
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8285
Joined: Mon Mar 24, 2008 19:52
Location: djakarta

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by andy1800 »

Nah, jd kenapa itu?
LAJUR KANAN... HARAP DISTERILKAN!

Image
pinan6
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 51
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2012 15:22

Re: ask: murano 2.5l 2010 atau cx5 touring??!!

Post by pinan6 »

Turboman wrote:Soal Murano.........udah pernah ngecek harga spare parts Murano belommm ya ?

Clue : kenapa mobil ini sangat jarang di jalan

Tanya kenapa ? :mrgreen:

jadi pengen cek juga nih ke showrrom nissan harga partnya
memang utk mobil premium, rasanya toyota yg terus berkibar