Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Mau review kendaraan yang ada? Silakan post disini...

Moderators: Ryan Steele, sh00t, r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze, akbarfit

User avatar
Turboman
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 22001
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 5:14

Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by Turboman »

Komparasi Duo bersaudara Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX oleh Caradvice

http://www.caradvice.com.au/279783/hold ... on-review/

In OZ the Trailblazer called = Holden Colorado 7

Seven-seat SUVs come in all shapes and sizes, but the vast majority of them offer little to no off-road prowess – enter the Holden Colorado 7 and Isuzu MU-X.

These two Thai-built, ute-based SUVs are designed to offer a budget alternative to the likes of the Toyota Prado, while also competing with the likes of the Mitsubishi Challenger.

The Holden and Isuzu are essentially two stand-alone versions of the same car: fraternal twins, if you will, as they are certainly not identical.

Holden Colorado 7 v Isuzu MU-X

The bodies of the two cars are very similar and the interiors are essentially the same design, but while the basic ladder-on-frame chassis’ are identical, each has unique suspension setups and steering calibrations, not to mention different engines and transmissions.

The Colorado 7 is available in two trim levels, both with four-wheel-drive as standard – LT, priced at $46,990; and LTZ, priced at $50,490. The latter is the model we’re testing here.

For that expenditure, buyers get a reverse-view camera and rear parking sensors, 18-inch alloy wheels with a 16-inch spare, leather-trimmed seats, electric seat adjustment for the driver, single-zone climate control air-conditioning, projector headlights and LED tail-lights, and Holden’s handy MyLink media system with USB, Bluetooth phone and audio streaming and voice control.



The Isuzu MU-X has a broader range of options to choose from, with a pair of 4×2 models priced at $40,500 (LS-M) and $42,000 (LS-U) respectively, and three 4×4 variants available: LS-M, priced at $45,600; LS-U, priced at $47,100; and the range-topping LS-T tested here, priced at $53,500 (though Isuzu is promoting the LS-T at $49,990 drive-away).

The LS-T model comes standard with a reverse-view camera and rear parking sensors, leather seats, climate control air-con and projector lights, 17-inch wheels with a full-size spare, and a touch-screen media system with USB, Bluetooth phone and audio streaming and an in-built satellite navigation system with off-road maps. There’s also a 10.0-inch flip-down DVD screen for rear-seat passengers.

Both cars have seven seats, both can tow up to 3.0 tonnes (braked capacity), and both have turbo-diesel four-cylinder engines.



The Colorado 7 is powered by a 2.8-litre turbo diesel that produces 147kW of power at 3600rpm, and a healthy 500Nm of torque from 2000rpm. Holden claims a consumption figure of 9.2 litres per 100km. On test we saw a little higher than that, with an average of 9.9L/100km over more than 250km of varied testing.

That engine is a strong and willing thing, with good mid-range response and plenty of grunt on the move – and clearly more than its rival. However, around town it is slow from a standstill before lurching to life as the torque kicks in rather abrasively, and at idle it rumbles in an unsophisticated manner, sending unwanted vibrations through the cabin.

The Colorado 7 makes use of a standard six-speed automatic in both trim levels. It works well during highway driving by allowing the engine to use its torque, but it can hunt for the right gear at lower speeds. It was also particularly active during off-road duties. We’ll come to that soon.



The Isuzu carries over what is essentially the same engine that has been seen in the D-Max ute range. Despite the engine’s larger 3.0-litre capacity, the Isuzu is down considerably on power – it produces 130kW at 3600rpm and 380Nm between 1800-2800rpm. It gains ground back with its fuel use, claimed at 8.4L/100km. We saw a higher figure of 10.1L/100km during our time.

The Isuzu’s engine offers more linear power delivery, revving more smoothly from low revs with less turbo lag. The torque deficit is noticeable – during overtaking manoeuvres, for example – but the MU-X’s powerplant is more refined and relaxing, particularly in stop-start traffic. There’s also considerably less clatter and vibration at idle.

Swapping cogs for the Isuzu is a five-speed automatic, which comes standard on the LS-T but is optional on all other 4×4 MU-X variants. The transmission is slightly clumsy at times, but hunts less during urban duties. At speed it is more likely to drop a gear to help keep things moving rather than relying on the engine’s torque – which has a negative effect on fuel use.



There’s no disguising the rugged ute underpinnings of either of these SUV spinoffs, and neither manages to offer a plush on-road experience – though the Isuzu does have the edge in this regard.

The Colorado 7 has a crude nature about its driving dynamics – the suspension lacks compliance and the ride never feels settled or composed. Occupants will feel all the bumps on the road surface, and the driver will notice plenty through their hands, as the steering offers inexcusable levels of play and kickback. It is less of an issue on the freeway, but during city driving it quickly becomes tedious.

The Isuzu is the lesser of two evils during commuting. It feels far more composed, isolating smaller bumps from the cabin, and dealing with larger inconsistencies adeptly. There’s less clumsiness all around, and the steering feels more direct and better calibrated.



The story is similar off road – while both have switchable four-wheel-drive systems that can be triggered between high range two- and four-wheel-drive on the fly, though switching to four-wheel-drive low range requires you to stop and have the gear selector in neutral.

The MU-X offers better body control over when it comes to the rough stuff, with its suspension allowing for better rebound over larger obstacles and a smoother drive experience on coarse roads. We put it through its paces, and it proved itself more than capable over a slippery, craggy hill climb and descent, and its steering feels quicker and more intuitive when negotiating mud or loose gravel surfaces.

The Colorado 7’s off-road abilities are almost identical to the Isuzu. Over the same slippery surfaces it crept down with the assistance of an active hill descent control system, something the Isuzu misses out on. The steering is a little less direct, and the aforementioned steering play did dampen its effectiveness on loose surfaces. Its ride was also coarser.



Inside, both models have enough room for seven average-sized adults, with the third row in each car surprisingly decent for leg- and head-room and reasonably easy to get into and out of courtesy of a flip-fold second row. That rear row eats in to boot space for both cars, with 235 litres of cargo room meaning family buyers who plan to use all the seats may need a storage pod or trailer for holidays. With five seats in use, the boot increases to more than 800L.

Both have ventilation for all three rows – ideal for cars like these – and full-length curtain airbag protection (along with dual front and front-side ‘bags).

In terms of interior design, both have a similar look but a very different feel. The Colorado’s plastics are rougher, but it has a digital speedometer and a driver’s side vanity mirror that the MU-X misses out on, and it is a lighter space which could be a positive for some buyers. The MyLink media system is simple to use but you need to have your phone to stream the sat-nav system, which could chew data and battery life quickly, and the app doesn’t have off-road tracks.



The MU-X’s interior plastics feel smoother to the touch and are of a higher perceived quality. We liked the darker fabrics, and the leather felt suppler. That navigation system with off-road maps is a bonus.

When it comes to ownership, the Isuzu has a five-year, 130,000 km warranty and five-year roadside assistance package. However, the Japanese brand doesn’t offer any form of capped price servicing at this point in time.

Holden, on the other hand, has capped price servicing for three years or 60,000km, with each visit costing a maximum of $295. Services are required every nine months or 15,000km, whichever occurs sooner. The Holden does have a less comprehensive warranty, though, at three years or 100,000km.

There’s no denying both of these cars achieve their objective of offering a more affordable alternative to the traditional off-roader crowd. But the Isuzu MU-X is a more refined offering than the Holden Colorado 7, and certainly more liveable if you spend the majority of your time on the road.


IMHO:
Itu apa iklan terselubung Isuzu yaa........or jika emang betul spt itu, maka MU-X benar2 bikin penasaran........

Image

Image
Image
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
* Bukan ajakan Beli *
User avatar
Turboman
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 22001
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 5:14

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by Turboman »

Wah sepi respon euyyyy
:e-think: :mky_01:

Padahal mobil2 kayak gini yg cocok utk jalanan di Indonesia
* Bukan ajakan Beli *
smgandi
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1400
Joined: Fri Jul 28, 2006 0:14

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by smgandi »

Wah kasihan, ya udah ane bantu. Ane tambahin videonya aja. :frm_tumbright: :frm_tumbleft:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wTj_4E1HvgA
Vorsprung durch Technik
The Pursuit of Perfection
From Zero to Hero
Air Tenang Menghanyutkan
Ilmu Padi
Good_boy86
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 977
Joined: Fri Sep 01, 2006 17:51
Location: sby

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by Good_boy86 »

Tampang depannya lebih keren colorado...
Mu x kapan masuk indonesia?
User avatar
Turboman
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 22001
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 5:14

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by Turboman »

Thx um smgandi utk video nya

Ya mobil2 spt gini yg cocok utk medan jalanan di Indonesia........dimana :
- Musim ujan tiba langsung jalan raya jadi jalan "lubang" raya....bahkan termasuk jalan tol
- Hujan dan banjir / genangan
* Bukan ajakan Beli *
aerotourersora
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 192
Joined: Sun Nov 17, 2013 10:25
Location: Buahbatu - Ciwastra
Daily Vehicle: Toyota Veloz

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by aerotourersora »

Turboman wrote:Thx um smgandi utk video nya

Ya mobil2 spt gini yg cocok utk medan jalanan di Indonesia........dimana :
- Musim ujan tiba langsung jalan raya jadi jalan "lubang" raya....bahkan termasuk jalan tol
- Hujan dan banjir / genangan
nunggu MU-X 2.5 a/t aja deh, TB 2.8 udah kemahalan :ngacir:
continuously-variable
jason28
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 645
Joined: Tue Dec 31, 2013 4:38

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by jason28 »

Ini isuzu yg re-badge trailblazer ya? :big_think: tapi TB di indonesia langka euy :mky_03:
User avatar
Turboman
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 22001
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 5:14

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by Turboman »

jason28 wrote:Ini isuzu yg re-badge trailblazer ya? :big_think: tapi TB di indonesia langka euy :mky_03:
Bukan re-badge tapi join project

sebab mesin dan powertrain sendiri2....si GM pake buatan mereka sendiri demikian juga Isuzu

CMIIW
* Bukan ajakan Beli *
glendotan
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 505
Joined: Thu Jul 21, 2011 5:44

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by glendotan »

Jd inget panther touring vs chevy tavera... serupa tp tak sama..
User avatar
Turboman
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 22001
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 5:14

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by Turboman »

Isuzu D-Max model baru dan Chevy Colorado baru juga platformnya sama khan, tapi mesin dan powertrain sendiri2

Kalo yg D-Max lama dan Colorado sebelum ini malah semi re-badge, beda model depan, mesin semua pake Isuzu punya
* Bukan ajakan Beli *
User avatar
Turboman
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 22001
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 5:14

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by Turboman »

Mobil2 yg cocok utk kondisi cuaca yg makin tahun makin tak terduga

Kita lihat aja durasi hujan di Jakarta, makin ke sini makin sering hujan yg sekali turun bisa 5 jam non stop.....hanya pelan - kenceng - pelan kenceng, tapi gak berenti2

Image

Serta merek2 lain yg punya Ground clearance tinggi

yang repot tuh jika pas kita pergi kering, lalu mendadak hujan super deras........dlm 2 - 3 jam genangan muncul dimana2........mobil tinggi akan tetap melintas tanpa khawatir

Dan di saat musim hujan lubang2 lgs bermunculan dimana2......bikin "hancur" pelan2 kaki2 mobil2 yg kaki2-nya lemah
* Bukan ajakan Beli *
User avatar
billyd1773dz
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 4354
Joined: Tue Sep 02, 2008 0:19
Location: Bandungers

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by billyd1773dz »

seadainya saat muncul genangan,ga khawatir jalan jadi macet karna ngantri nungguin mobil lain lewat............ apalagi bgtu ada yg mogok dan harus nunggu di evakuasi dulu......




*pernah kejebak macet 8jam di rancaekek* boil sih yakin lewat..... apadaya banjirnya masih beberapa km di depan minim tempat uturn, pembatas jalan juga terlalu tinggi untuk di loncatin. engine off bobo aja deh wkwkw

dan pedangan sepanjang jalan itu yg bahagia laris manis.
:beer:
just my dummy head.... me available on youtube! check n subs ya!
Image Billyd1773dz
User avatar
Turboman
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 22001
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 5:14

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by Turboman »

billyd1773dz wrote:seadainya saat muncul genangan,ga khawatir jalan jadi macet karna ngantri nungguin mobil lain lewat............ apalagi bgtu ada yg mogok dan harus nunggu di evakuasi dulu......




*pernah kejebak macet 8jam di rancaekek* boil sih yakin lewat..... apadaya banjirnya masih beberapa km di depan minim tempat uturn, pembatas jalan juga terlalu tinggi untuk di loncatin. engine off bobo aja deh wkwkw

dan pedangan sepanjang jalan itu yg bahagia laris manis.
:beer:
betul

bbrp kali ane lihat di GunSa mobil2 pada antri masuk jalur buswey karena jalanan sampingnya tergenang.....sementara mobil2 tinggi melaju tenang di jalan tergenang

Daerah rawan juga depan Citraland - Untar FE.......Ipah ane pernah lewat situ dimana permukaan air dah nyentuh2 bawah dek......padahal Ipah ane udah lebih tinggi drpd Ipah std
* Bukan ajakan Beli *
glendotan
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 505
Joined: Thu Jul 21, 2011 5:44

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by glendotan »

Turboman wrote:Isuzu D-Max model baru dan Chevy Colorado baru juga platformnya sama khan, tapi mesin dan powertrain sendiri2

Kalo yg D-Max lama dan Colorado sebelum ini malah semi re-badge, beda model depan, mesin semua pake Isuzu punya

Kalo mesin dan powertrain beda berarti part beda juga nih... Mudah2an spare partnya terjangkau sebagai ciri khas Isuzu...
Prestige
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1172
Joined: Thu Jul 11, 2013 14:03

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by Prestige »

Thread na sepi bkn krna gitu om
Krna d indo ada PS dan fortie yg bsa gntiin si TB ini :big_slap:
*kidding om

Ni mobil bagus tpi kemahalan
Ga sanggup eui :frm_bang_head:
User avatar
Turboman
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 22001
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 5:14

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by Turboman »

glendotan wrote:
Kalo mesin dan powertrain beda berarti part beda juga nih... Mudah2an spare partnya terjangkau sebagai ciri khas Isuzu...
Kalo ngeliat di D-Max baru spt-nya Isuzu menerapkan spt itu scr bertahap ya

Konon price list filter solarnya cuman 45.000 (walau filter buatan Sakura)

Filter solar D-Max yg 2012 ke belakang juga murah
* Bukan ajakan Beli *
User avatar
Xous
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1239
Joined: Mon Nov 16, 2009 6:20
Location: Surabaya

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by Xous »

@om turbo, btw knp y si chevy ni langka bgt, d jalanan sby sy trakhir liat 5 bulan lalu, klo yg d-cab sebulan lalu, masa seh fortie n pjs segitu menancap d kelas ini, new everrest aja msh keliatan, jg seakan2 captiva lbh bagus drpd nih trailblazer, ane rekomen tmn jg g minat, akhirnya tetep ambil captiva. Sayang bgt pdhl asyik modelnya.
smgandi
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1400
Joined: Fri Jul 28, 2006 0:14

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by smgandi »

Prestige wrote:Thread na sepi bkn krna gitu om
Krna d indo ada PS dan fortie yg bsa gntiin si TB ini :big_slap:
*kidding om

Ni mobil bagus tpi kemahalan
Ga sanggup eui :frm_bang_head:
Masa sanggup pakai CR-V Prestige, nggak sanggup pakai TB? Yg bener aje.
Vorsprung durch Technik
The Pursuit of Perfection
From Zero to Hero
Air Tenang Menghanyutkan
Ilmu Padi
ricz
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 12275
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 10:18
Location: Indonesia

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by ricz »

Rada aneh juga sih...

Klo misalkan sodara kembar beda muka sih seharusnya kualitet interior hampir sama...

Mencurigai bau2 iklan terselubung :mky_04:
2021 Fortuner VRZ
smgandi
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1400
Joined: Fri Jul 28, 2006 0:14

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by smgandi »

Xous wrote:@om turbo, btw knp y si chevy ni langka bgt, d jalanan sby sy trakhir liat 5 bulan lalu, klo yg d-cab sebulan lalu, masa seh fortie n pjs segitu menancap d kelas ini, new everrest aja msh keliatan, jg seakan2 captiva lbh bagus drpd nih trailblazer, ane rekomen tmn jg g minat, akhirnya tetep ambil captiva. Sayang bgt pdhl asyik modelnya.
Kalo ane lihat sih gara2 nih TB miskin varian. Saat ini yg laku adalah varian dgn transmisi matic. Sedangkan TB cuma punya 2 varian 2.5L 4x2 M/T dan 2.8L 4x4 A/T. Coba ditambah 1 varian lagi 2.5L 4x2 A/T, ane rasa angka penjualannya akan lain. Kalau mau dilengkapi variannya sih mustinya ada varian 2.5L 4x4 M/T dan 2.8L 4x2 A/T.
Vorsprung durch Technik
The Pursuit of Perfection
From Zero to Hero
Air Tenang Menghanyutkan
Ilmu Padi
smgandi
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1400
Joined: Fri Jul 28, 2006 0:14

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by smgandi »

ricz wrote:Rada aneh juga sih...

Klo misalkan sodara kembar beda muka sih seharusnya kualitet interior hampir sama...

Mencurigai bau2 iklan terselubung :mky_04:
Kalau ane lihat sih TB emang diposisikan lebih tinggi dari MU-X.
Vorsprung durch Technik
The Pursuit of Perfection
From Zero to Hero
Air Tenang Menghanyutkan
Ilmu Padi
smgandi
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1400
Joined: Fri Jul 28, 2006 0:14

Re: Komparasi Chevy Trailblazer VS Isuzu MUX - Caradvice

Post by smgandi »

Ada video menarik dari MU-X.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpMJl4VRQIM
Vorsprung durch Technik
The Pursuit of Perfection
From Zero to Hero
Air Tenang Menghanyutkan
Ilmu Padi